Hacker Perspective: Thermostat Signals

Three and a half categories (in this article)

Thermostat	Smart	Batteries?	Notes
Mechanical	0	n/a	usually interfaces with all residential heating-cooling systems
Programmable 1	1	Y	1a) usually interfaces with most older (pre-Y2K) heating-cooling systems 1b) only will interface with heating-cooling systems via a control-line isolation device
Programmable 2	2	N	requires a C-wire; often supports connecting to your WiFi

Preface

1. I've been working in the computer industry for more than 40 years where hardware and wiring is documented to the ninth power. Unfortunately this is not the case in the heating-cooling business where it appears that every company has gone in their own direction. For example, check out this Nov-2020 except from Wikipedia on the Thermostat article: 

   "There are no standards for wiring color codes, but convention has settled on the following terminal codes and colors. In all cases, the manufacturer's instructions should be considered definitive".

2. I had no experience with thermostat wiring until 1985 when I bought a Honeywell programmable thermostat as a replacement for my mechanical thermostat (which was connected to a mid-efficiency natural-gas furnace). The instructions back then suggested "taking note of which wire colors were connected to which labeled terminals. then just moving the wires to the new thermostat base". There was a 1-800 telephone that you could call if you got into trouble with a second suggestion about calling a qualified heat-cooling service technician
3. In the early 1990s I did some consulting work for a Kitchener-based manufacturer of ground-source heat pumps by the name of Earth Systems. I met industry insiders who had spent decades in the heating-cooling business who did not seem to think the lack of a standard for terminals codes or color codes was a big deal. Oh well...
4. In 1997 I hired a contractor to add a cooling option (a.k.a. air-conditioning) to my residence so I was off to a big box store for a better thermostat (IIRC, it was another Honeywell with a larger LCD display). No surprise here: the instructions left something to be desired -AND- the industry had not moved to any kind of standardization.
5. In 2010 I bought a RONA-branded thermostat from RONA (a Canadian big box store) that featured 12 programmable slots (weekdays x 4; Saturday x4; Sunday x 4). The model number (from the back) is THM303 and appears to have been manufactured somewhere in Asia then imported by UPM Marketing. Still no wiring standardization.
6. In 2019 my air-conditioning died and a contractor talked me into also replacing my mid-efficiency furnace with a high-efficiency model (greater than 90%). In order to get my circa-2010 thermostat to work, they needed to add an isolation device between the thermostat and furnace. Why? Most battery-powered thermostats are actually powered by "stealing a tiny amount of power from the signal lines" (the batteries would be dead in 7-10 days if this were not so) but high efficiency furnaces sometimes employ high efficiency control circuits which can no longer tolerate parasitic powering of the thermostat.
7. In 2020 we experienced a power outage for a few hours. Later that day after a short visit with relatives, we returned at 19:30 then noticed our house was already at 28 C (6 C above the set-point of 22 C). The clock on the thermostat was frozen at 15:45 which means the CPU (if there was one) had probably been insane for over 4 hours. I wonder what would have happened if we were on vacation?.
   • I am a hardware hacker with a background in electronics and formal training from Conestoga College. I carefully disassembled this unit to determine where it was manufactured.
   • The PCB only contains ENGLISH but has no manufacturer's logo or country of origin. The PCB does contain the iconic backward RU (R connected to U) which is a subset of Underwriters Laboratories
   • I could not find a CPU or any other chips but there is something under a black glob which appears to also drive the LCD display.
8. I replaced this unit with the Honeywell Home RTH9585WF. This unit does not require batteries but I did not know that until I attempted to install it. It was at this time that a little page dropped out of the box titled "C-Wire Addendum" and I wondered what is the C wire? Some sites, like this one at Wikipedia, claim than "C" is "ground" but that cannot possibly be correct since I opened my furnace then poked around with a DVM only to discover that raw 24VAC power sits between RC + RH (which are usually linked together when a common control board in the furnace control both heating and cooling).

In the beginning...

In the early days of residential heating (or heating-cooling) system designers went out of their way to keep everyone safe.

1. Control systems are usually powered by a 24 VAC transformer rather than line voltage (115 VAC in North America; 230 VAC in Europe)
2. Raw power was never sent through the wires. One side of the transformer output was connected to the control relays. The other side was sent to the thermostat which only needed to close a circuit to, for example, call for heat.
3. Not sending raw power through this circuit will also protect you from blowing a fuse if:
   1. you wired the thermostat incorrectly
   2. you inadvertently shorted the wires by doing an installation with the power TURNED ON
   3. you inadvertently drove a nail into the thermostat wiring
      • might not cause a short circuit but still could be dangerous by permanently calling for heat - WHICH COULD CAUSE A FIRE
      • on some systems it is possible to call for HEAT and call for COOL at the same time. Yikes!
   Caveat: some systems do not protect the 24-volt supply with a fuse (or they did but some bozo might have replaced the inline fuse with jumper wire). In these instances any wiring errors could burn out the transformer and/or CAUSE A FIRE

Mechanical 24-volt thermostats

A heating-only Honeywell-T87 is shown to the right (I remember this exact product in my father's home in the 1950s and 1960s; notice the Fahrenheit scale). It works by rotating a coiled bimetallic strip with a mercury bulb attached to the very end.

Overview

• why bimetallic? Temperature causes different metals to expand (when heated) or contract (when cooled) at different rates. When a coiled spring is constructed of two different metal strips (one one each side), differences in length will cause the spring to rotate
• why mercury bulb? When the ball of mercury rolls down the tube, the weight of the mercury will rotate the spring slightly, locking in the action (no electrical stuttering). Scientists and technologists refer to this as hysteresis.

Links:

• https://www.edn.com/dumb-thermostat-provides-power-smarts-without-software/
• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermostat#24_volt_thermostats (contains common "signal names" and "usual wire colors")

Comments:

• only two wires were usually connected in this unit ("heat call" and "heat return") since the fan only ran when the furnace pushed hot air into the plenum. See the next section to see the signal names and descriptions.

Time moves on:

• A more modern version of the T87 thermostat is the T87N seen with the heating-cooling base. This product is advertised as mercury-free because it does not employ bimetallic strip(s)
• caveats:
  • placing a "C" before these part numbers gets you a thermostat with a Celsius scale (used everywhere in the world except the USA)
  • Honeywell no longer makes or supports thermostats. They sold the name to www.resideo.com who market them under the brand Honeywell Home

(some) Schematic Diagrams and Their Signals

The following schematic diagrams were printed on a sticker affixed to the base of the thermostat base of the THM303A I purchased at a Canadian big-box store in 2010. The diagrams below were extracted from page-14 of the (non-copyrighted) associated manual which I am only presenting here for discussion purposes. See the following table for a discussion of the signals.

Notes:

1. Many times RC and RH are linked together at the thermostat base (but never when two transformers are used; see the 5-wire diagram)
2. Why are RH and RC  known as "return lines"? Inspect this example of residential electrician wiring
   • inspect the so-called "Alternative - California Style" where raw power is first connected to the load (a light bulb in this case) which early "electrical codes" thought were a little safer since raw power was never sent to the switch.
   • as soon as you replace the light switch with a receptacle (outlet) the the conventional wiring seems a little more safe (while raw power is going to the switch, powering off the switch totally depowers a "switched receptacle"
   so "call lines" like W, Y and G are best thought of as "travelers" in the parlance of electricians. CAVEAT: your local "electrical code" always supersedes anything you see on the internet.

Programmable-1

• in my categorization, type-1 programmable thermostats require batteries but also require power (they steal parasitically) from the heating-cooling control lines. If they did not do this then the batteries would only last 7-10 days.
• These should be able to directly connect to older heating-cooling systems where the small current stolen will not activate a relay (eg. call for heat)
• These may need an isolation device in order to connect to newer heating-cooling systems (here, the relays in the heating-cooling system are so sensitive that the thermostat parasitic current would be misinterpreted as a call (eg. call for heat)

observations-extrapolations

• Think about this for a moment: Each battery generates 1.5 VDC and there are usually 2-4 of them in these thermostats meaning they require somewhere between 3 to 6 VDC.
• The control lines are powered by 24 VAC which means that sampling resistors would need to be connected to one (or more) signal lines
• The output from this network could then be run into a rectifier (half-wave = cheap implementation; full-wave = better) to convert the AC into DC
• A clever resistor-network design would also provide the primary voltage drop from 24 (RMS) to the final 3 to 6
  comment: these are commodity devices where every penny counts. If it were not so then the designer would implement a proper switched-mode supply which could produce the exact voltage most efficiently

Programmable-2

• In my categorization, type-2 programmable thermostats require a direct power connection from the heating-cooling equipment
• This reason for this is the higher power requirements of putting a real CPU chip (with EEPROM and RAM) into the thermostat in order to support things like:
  • large colored touch screen with back-light
  • Wi-Fi interface (which can also tell your the outside temperature once it knows your postal code after you register it here: https://www.mytotalconnectcomfort.com
• Thermostats like the Honeywell Home RTH9585WF require an additional connection known as the C-wire. Here is the quote from their manual

  Important! C wire is required and is the power source for your thermostat. Without a C wire, your thermostat will not power up.

  and here https://www.honeywellhome.com/us/en/support/everything-you-need-to-know-about-a-c-wire/
• I did not have a C-wire behind my old thermostat so needed to run an additional solid 18-guage wire to my furnace (Rheem/Ruud high-efficiency natural gas) which did have a signal terminal labeled "C". You can buy this stuff at any big-box store but I just bought a package of thermostat wire from Canadian Tire.
• I noticed that the RH + RC at the thermostat were connected to "R" at the furnace
• I used a DVM to prove that "R" at the furnace was one side of the 24 VAC transformer whist "C" was on the other side (so this is raw 24 VAC power)
• comment: "I think" that this terminal was labeled "C" for "common". Why? If you inspect the 4-wire and 5-wire schematics (above) you will notice that this is a common connecting point for the relays

Links

• NSR's climate science
• NSR's introduction to climate modeling
• Thermostats
  • From Wikipedia:
    • https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermostat
    • https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermostat#24_volt_thermostats (chart of common signal names)
• Residential Electrical Wiring
  • http://www.electrical101.com/switch-wiring-using-nm-cable.html
  • https://www.thespruce.com/tips-for-wiring-outlets-and-switches-1824668
  • https://www.familyhandyman.com/list/wiring-switches-and-outlets/
  • https://www.thespruce.com/electrical-basics-101-1152377